She was pulled into the water by her left arm. Jan Topoleski told investigators that "Dawn was lying on her stomach Tilikum was interacting with her nose to nose. And I didnt know about any of them until after I left SeaWorld. Much about Brancheau's last moments was known. Tilikum has been involved twice before in human deaths. Yet it cannot remove the element of unpredictability inherent in working with killer whales. Upon applying for the permit, SeaWorld hadnt even looked at the incident report about the Sealand trainers death, and after being urged by the NMFS to do so, SeaWorld attributed the previous attack to a design flaw at Sealand. "He had a great relationship with her, and she had a great relationship with him. As Dawn Brancheau lay next to Tilikum, petting him in just a few inches of water, she likely had no reason to suspect that she was about to be torn apart. That park visitor Jessica Wilder of Vermont told investigators she saw Brancheau lying on a platform, hugging Tilikum and feeding him fish. Trainer Lynne Schaber told investigators she knew Brancheau was in trouble when Tilikum pulled her into the water because the killer whale "normally keeps things that he has and will not release them." Stacy Nichols was working on the Dine with Shamu show when she observed Tilikum do a "deep dive" to the bottom of the tank with a trainer in his mouth. Want all the latest shocking news and views from all over the world straight into your inbox? We use your sign-up to provide content in the ways you've consented to and improve our understanding of you. Or by navigating to the user icon in the top right. Dawn, an experienced SeaWorld trainer, died of 'drowning and traumatic injuries' after she was mauled by Tilikum, a 5.4 tonne orca measuring more than 22ft in length.. [6][28] This internal, voluntary prohibition was similar to what had happened after some other injuries to animal trainers. Delivering what was perhaps the most horrific detail of all, the report told how Dawn arrived at the morgue in two parts - her battered, broken body totally disconnected from her scalp. Some SeaWorld visitors witnessed Dawn's struggle with Tilikum, including a boy who reportedly . [58], In 2011, Florida passed Statute 406.136, which provides for confidentiality of media obtained by public agencies that depicts or records the killing of a person. The 41-year-old was snatched and dragged into the water during a live show so quickly that no one saw it happening - not . Cloud, formerly of Cedar Lake, Ind., passed away February 24, 2010 doing what she loved. But during one well practised segment, where she lay down to kiss the huge 30-year-old mammal, he grabbed her, dragging her in to the pool and under the water. Some witnesses reported seeing Tilikum grab Brancheau by the ponytail or shoulder. His sperm was used to father over half the orcas at SeaWorlds parks, even though he killed three humans. Something went wrong, please try again later. The family launched The Dawn Brancheau Foundation a year after her death to mark her 42nd birthday. IN THE CARE OF. Dawn Brancheau developed a "close bond" with a SeaWorld orca called Tilikum. [4][5][11][12] She graduated from the University of South Carolina with degrees in psychology and animal behavior. The report read: "Also received with the body is a portion of the scalp with attached hair and a fragment of red-pink muscle.". Celebrate the life of Dawn Brancheau, leave a kind word or memory and get funeral service information care of . OSHA did state that it would accept other means of protection as long as it provided equal or greater safety as the physical barriers. It is the first minute-by-minute account of the accident. [4] Judge and later Supreme Court Justice Brett Kavanaugh, a dissenting judge in a legal case involving her death (see below), stated that "To be fearless, courageous, tough to perform a sport or activity at the highest levels of human capacity, even in the face of known physical risk is among the greatest forms of personal achievement for many who take part in these activities. The 40-year-old trainer was at ease with the killer whale and had just petted him on the nose. [31] Brancheau was the third fatality associated with Tilikum[4][8] and the fourth by a captive orca. An autopsy ruled that he died of hypothermia in the 50-degree water. This was precisely the issue at the center of the Occupational Safety and Health Administrations (OSHA) investigation. Topoleski, a trainer for SeaWorld Orlando, turned to push an alarm. But when he looked back, 5ft 1ins Dawn was nowhere to be seen. She was cautious and always abided by the parks safety guidelines when she was around the orcas. On February 24, a day with the whales turned into a nightmare for tourists and SeaWorld staff. The report also showed that she dislocated her left elbow and left knee and had lacerations on her right ear. It ended with the violent death of 40-year-old Dawn Brancheau, who worked there for 15 years. Dawn Therese Brancheau, 40, of St. She suffered spinal cord injuries, and her ribs as well as bones in her legs, arms, and face were broken. CLOUDE, FL FORMERLY OF CEDAR LAKE Dawn Therese Brancheau (nee Lo Verde), 40, of St. Dawn's long hair floated on the water in to Tilikum's mouth.". Local government investigators and OSHA had obtained SeaWorld's video surveillance footage, which captured her death, as well as photographs, which showed the effects of the attack. FOR years Dawn Brancheau dreamed of working at SeaWorld - but it was a job that ultimately killed her when she was attacked by Tilikum the orca. As always you can unsubscribe at any time. By various witness accounts Brancheau was on a platform in the water, laying on her belly, performing nose to nose with the whale when her ponytail went into his mouth. Dawn Therese Brancheau, 40, of St. [3][14] The Shamu show's interaction of animal trainers with orcas was regarded as SeaWorld's star attraction. [11][12] Away from work, she volunteered at a local animal shelter,[4] looked after two chocolate Labradors,[13] and kept a variety of stray ducks, chickens, rabbits, and small birds at her home. In the same statement, they went on to note that Dawn would not have remained a trainer at SeaWorld for 15 years if she felt that the whales were not well cared for.[49], Brancheau's death has been seen as a factor in starting a trajectory of recalibration for SeaWorld. Tell us in the comments below. Her grisly death, which happened during a Dine With Shamu show at the park in Orlando, Florida, was caught on camera as tourists were filming the spectacle, expecting to see tricks. When the alarm sounded, one of SeaWorld's surveillance videos focused on the pool captured Brancheau, 40, as she briefly broke free from the killer whale. An autopsy report released Wednesday confirmed that a SeaWorld trainer killed after a 12,000-pound killer whale pulled her underwater died of drowning and traumatic injuries to her body, including . Tilikum the orca, infamous for killing two people previously in marine water parks, dragged SeaWorld trainer Dawn Brancheau into a swim tank on February 24, 2010. [48], Her family has said they are grateful that the film has brought attention to the issue of animal welfare. To stay up to date with all the latest news, make sure you sign up to one of our newsletters here. [3][4] She worked with orcas at SeaWorld Orlando for fifteen years, including a leading role in revamping the Shamu show,[3][5] and was SeaWorld's poster girl. Unless a judge intervenes, the material will become public under Florida law once the Orange County Sheriff's Office concludes its investigation. I do believe that he loved her, and I know that she loved him.". But her autopsy report was truly harrowing, Don't miss a thing! This was cause enough for him to turn around to push the alarm button. Employees used nets and threw food in the water in an attempt to distract him. [17] The autopsy concluded that Dukes' cause of death was drowning. That they had a relationship built on trust made the events of their final meeting all the more horrifying. [48] Cowperthwaite's background research suggested to her that there were problems with keeping captive orcas; SeaWorld disagreed, characterizing the film as propaganda. Dawn Brancheau. ORLANDO, Fla. A SeaWorld Orlando trainer attacked by a killer whale died of drowning and blunt-force trauma to her head, neck and torso, an autopsy released Wednesday showed. Cloud, FL . Emily Atack won't stop accepting sexy TV roles despite cruel online trolls, The Inbetweeners actress and comedian Emily Atack has vowed to keep accepting racy on-screen roles despite the horrific abuse she's received from online abusers, Police hunt for East London gang setting foxes on fire with 'lighter fluid', The sickening criminals have reportedly been torturing foxes, setting them on fire, and smoking out their dens with police are appealing for more information from the public. Instead, he pulled the 40-year-old trainer into his tank. New in the final report was: A synopsis of. He also refused to 'release' her body for a whole 45 minutes, despite more than two dozen staff trying to distract him with food and catch him in nets to stop his frenzied attack and retrieve the remains of their colleague. WARNING: Graphic and upsetting content. SeaWorld has removed Tilikum from its daily shows and ordered its trainers to keep their distance from the animal. So I think thats a serious mistake on SeaWorlds part that they werent letting people know the history of all the animals.. [35][36] OSHA maintained that SeaWorld "willfully" endangered its employees and stated that the company "(shows) Plain indifference to, or intentional disregard for, employee safety and health." The one-day debate between animal-rights activists and theme-park operators in Washington centered on the educational value of parks such as SeaWorld. The 43-page report, released Wednesday, represents that final investigative document related to the SeaWorld accident, one that drew international attention and prompted a congressional subcommittee hearing this week about oversight of businesses that feature wildlife acts. At just 2 years old, he was torn from his mother and their ocean home and sent to the rundown marine park Sealand of the Pacific. 7 While all attention is focused on Tilikum and Blackfish, with SeaWorld and their supporters picking spots off the film, the death of one of their other trainers by an orca born and bred at SeaWorld seems to be going unnoticed. She had bruises and cuts all over her body. Perhaps most importantly, why did SeaWorlds then-owner try to blame his own orca trainer for her deatheven after the OSHA investigation uncovered that the same safety measures and recall signals that had failed to prevent Dawn Brancheaus death had been failing for years? In this case he seemed to hold on to Brancheau as if she were his possession, by one witness account. In 2010, she was tragically killed by Tilikum, the largest Killer Whale held in captivity. The animal attack was deemed accidental. In response, SeaWorlds vice president for animal training criticized their actions in a two-page document claiming that the show should not have been ended early because it brought unnecessary attention to the incident. He is twice as big as any other orca at the park. He added that he watched as she struggled to free her hair from the orca's mouth. Dawn Brancheau's death in a brutal and prolonged attack carried out by Tilikum, the killer whale made famous by the Blackfish film, shocked the world. While living her dream, she was a source of inspiration and joy to her family and friends. After approximately 45 minutes, Tilikum released Brancheau's body. As always you can unsubscribe at any time. Learn more about cruelty at SeaWorld on The PETA Podcast: Listen to more episodes on iTunes, Stitcher, and Spotify! And the most important thing that anyone can do to help imprisoned animals is to refuse to patronize marine or other abusement parks. SeaWorld wasnt even willing to put the life of its own star trainer before profit, so why should anyone trust that it would ever put the well-being of its captive animals first? Brancheau also appeared in a season four episode of Fetch! [8], Subsequently, in late May 2012, Judge Ken S. Welsch formally sided with OSHA over SeaWorld's orca safety practices. "Catastrophic" injuries sustained in the fatal attack were laid bare. She was lying with her face next to Tilikum's on a slide-out, which is a platform submerged about a foot into the water. [8] Welsch was sharply critical of SeaWorld's assertion that it was unaware that working with orcas posed a hazard to employees. Trainer and whale at SeaWorld Orlando | TUFKAAP | CC BY-SA 3.0, My understanding of the animals past was very limited. However, they also added that "Blackfish is not Dawn's story" and that "Since Dawn's death in 2010, the media has focused mainly on the whales. Prince Harry says he was 'perfect for military' as 'emotional pain worse than physical', Prince Harry said he found emotional pain "worse than physical pain" during an "intimate" interview with Dr Gabor Mat today as he opened up about the death of his mum, Princess Diana, 'Sonic boom' mystery that felt like 'explosion' to people across country is solved, People in Leicester, Oxford and Northampton all reported hearing a "sonic boom" that sounded like a "bomb had gone off" earlier today, causing ground shakes and the cause has finally been determined, BBC Breakfast host ends Lenny Henry chat as he warns 'you shouldn't say that', BBC Breakfast's Charlie Stayt abruptly ended his chat with Sir Lenny Henry on Thursday when the loveable comedian made a cheeky quip about getting free books from the library, Bride left in tears as 88 guests RSVP to wedding but over half don't show up, Gray and her partner Nyx were disappointed as they looked at the empty ceremony room where she was expecting 88 guests but less than 40 turned up to their wedding, Art Attack legend Neil Buchanan unrecognisable after quitting TV role for rock band, Neil Buchanan, best known for being the face of iconic CITV series Art Attack, looks worlds away from his clean-cut children's presenter days as a rock star, The Chase fans swoon over 'gorgeous' ITV player before she sparks complaints, The Chase viewers couldn't help but swoon over contestant Rachael who they branded 'gorgeous' - but the praise didn't last long after she made a shocking decision, Rebel Wilson claims Meghan Markle is 'not as warm' as 'lovely' Prince Harry, Recently engaged Rebel Wilson has recalled the moment she first met Prince Harry and Meghan Markle on a trip to California with her mum, claiming the Duchess was "not as cool", Pamela Anderson reveals she was 'painfully shy' before nude Playboy centrefold shoot, Former Baywatch star Pamela Anderson, 55, has opened up about the shyness she suffered from prior to appearing nude for Playboy, for whom she would be a cover star 14 times, New series of Mrs Brown's Boys heading to BBC despite lowest ever ratings, A new series of Mrs Brown's Boys has been confirmed despite a serious drop in ratings - but after only airing specials in recent years, a mini series is about to hit TV screens, Kim Kardashian 'ready to date again' but doesn't want famous Hollywood star partner, Kim Kardashian is on the lookout for a new relationship and wants to date someone who isn't a Hollywood star, a source close to the reality star has confirmed, TEE-RIFFIC: Golf influencer who is 'too beautiful' loves bikini shots and could rival Paige Spiranac, Golf influencer Waiyi Chan is growing in popularity with her glamorous Instagram posts and is seen as a possible rival for social media sensation Paige Spiranac, Bikini-clad carpenter claims 'old fashioned' co-workers don't like her racy work outfits, A female carpenter, who is known online as "The Bikini Woodworker", claims "old fashioned" people in the trade aren't a fan of her videos where she dons a two-piece swimsuit to work, Stephen Bears fiance breaks silence as reality star is jailed for revenge porn, Stephen Bear's fianc Jessica Smith threw her support behind the disgraced TV star, insisting she will "always" be by his side despite his 21-month prison sentence, Putin's 'secret brood of children' with ex-Olympic star 'raised in luxury', Vladimir Putin is said to be secretly raising several children with his alleged girlfriend, Alina Kabaeva, in a 'luxury forest palace' fit for a 'royal' as the leak reportedly comes from Kabaeva's friends, Love Island fans accuse bosses of 'hiding the real Lana' after spotting key clue, Love Island fans think the main show, which airs throughout the week, is doing Lana Jenkins 'dirty' with producers 'hiding' her personality and instead airing a 'scripted' show, Johnny Depp shocks locals with unexpected arrival at Lincolnshire antique shop, Pirates Of The Caribbean actor and Hollywood icon Johnny Depp rocked up and bought several guitars at the Lincolnshire antiques shop after arriving by helicopter, Rylan Clark admits bizarre phobia after being 'obsessed' with Monster Munch crisps, This Morning presenter Rylan Clark said he used to love eating Monster Munch crisps as a youngster, but things took a turn when he scoffed too many of the snacks, Erling Haaland loses the plot in scrap with Dan Burn - before laughing it off, Erling Haaland has bullied numerous defences since his arrival in the Premier League, but the Manchester City forward's took on his largest opponent yet - Dan Burn, Only 1% of players can find hidden ghost inside room in under 11 seconds. CCTV from the park showed Dawn entering the water at 13:38. The autopsy determined that Dawn Brancheau died of blunt force trauma to the head, neck and torso, and drowning when the giant orca yanked her into SeaWorld's pool Feb. 24. WARNING: Graphic content. Dawn Brancheau was born as Dawn Therese LoVerde on April 16, 1969 to Marion LoVerde and Charles LoVerde. SeaWorld Orlando spokeswoman Becca Bides said the park did not have any comment on the autopsy. Do you think marine parks and dolphin shows should be banned? Lynne told cops that she knew Dawn was in trouble as Tilikum was a 'possessive' animal, and once he had things in his mouth he would not release them. After Dawn's death Tilikum was moved to a new, much smaller tank where he was kept alone and reportedly lay lifeless, floating on the water. While living her dream, she was a source of inspiration and joy to her family and friends. In fact, there had been 30 incidents between killer whales, and trainers prior to my being hired at the park. Blackfish trailer shows story of SeaWorld orca Tilikum. According to witnesses who had worked with Tilikum, he was known as an animal that would not release items once he had them, which is definitely how he held onto Brancheau. The cause of death was officially recorded as "drowning and traumatic injuries" after blunt force trauma. Something went wrong, please try again later. It might have been an unusual dream for a girl from landlocked Indiana but . [42][43] In 2015, SeaWorld was cited again, in San Diego, for not adequately protecting orca trainers. [26], No SeaWorld trainer entered a pool to perform a show with an orca following Brancheau's death. trainers ended a show after an orca began to ignore signals, This was precisely the issue at the center of the Occupational Safety and Health Administrations (OSHA) investigation, SeaWorlds failure to generate an incident report. Each time, the temporary pause was then lifted by SeaWorld. That Topoleski told investigators trainers moved Tilikum into three different pools in their attempt to free Brancheau, but the orca would not release her. As if the incident itself wasn't harrowing enough, an autopsy report revealed Dawn, who had always dreamed of working with killer whales, suffered greatly in the beast's jaws. According to one of SeaWorlds own employees, the event was unpredictable and the orca gave no indication that he was about to grab her. The New York Times reported that Tilikum died of a bacterial infection on January 6, 2017. Even after her body had been retrieved from the water, Tilikum was antagonistic and appeared to keep attempting to get it. Tilikum finally found freedom from his notoriety - and the mundaneness of his daily life - when he died in January 2017. Her body was placed under a black sheet five feet away from the wall of 'D' pool. One of her SeaWorld colleagues is certain she "loved" the 12,000-pound orca and that he loved her back. [37] SeaWorld challenged the OSHA fine and the safety report in legal proceedings, stating that "OSHA's allegations in this citation are unsupported by any evidence or precedent and reflect a fundamental lack of understanding of the safety requirements associated with marine mammal care. He was swimming manically, only coming to the surface long enough to breathe before diving again. [15][16] In April 2014, the US Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia denied a "petition for review",[16][29][30] with later Supreme Court justice Brett Kavanaugh being the sole judge to side with SeaWorld. [19][23][24] At least a dozen patrons witnessed Brancheau in the water with Tilikum. "He never showed any indication that he looked at you as a play toy that he wanted to own," Tompkins said. They eventually coaxed Tilikum to release her by raising the bottom of one of the pools. Dawn had been working with Tilikum, SeaWorld Orlando's biggest orca, for 16 years, (Image: Tribune News Service via Getty Images), Dawn Brancheau had spent 16 years working closely with the killer whales at SeaWorld, This distressing image shows a black tarp covering Dawn Brancheau's body in the pool after the attack. Espaol; Franais; OBITUARY Dawn Therese Brancheau April 16, 1969 - February 24, 2010. An autopsy found numerous wounds, contusions, and abrasions covering his body that were caused by Tilikum. He argued that the trainers should have used other resources before canceling the show, despite SeaWorlds official position that trainers could end a show at any time if they felt uncomfortable. She also dislocated her left elbow and left ear. DISTURBING DETAILS FOUND IN SEAWORLD TRAINER DAWN BRANCHEAU'S AUTOPSY REPORT. Not long after Kelties death, Sealand closed its doors, and its orcas were purchased by SeaWorld. Much about Brancheau's last moments was known. In 2010, when SeaWorld animal trainer Dawn Therese Brancheau was attacked and killed by an orca, her family invoked the law to prevent release of videos of the attack. Gerardo Mora/Getty Images Killer whale "Tilikum" performs on March 30, 2011. a year after the six-ton whale killed trainer Dawn Brancheau. But the autopsy report has been released today, and it makes it very clear that Dawn Brancheaus last moments were filled with tremendous suffering. It marked the third time the animal, named Tilikum, had been involved in a human death. "[8], Welsch made it clear that his ruling only applies "to the work trainers do during shows and not at other times, such as during medical procedures or 'relationship-building' sessions As a custodian SeaWorld has an ethical duty to provide for the whales' needs husbandry activities require a certain amount of contact between the trainers and whales unlike performances, which can successfully continue without the trainers in the water." "There is no constitutional right to voyeurism and there is a constitutional right to privacy," Mills said. And why did SeaWorld continue to rely on those failed measures? The cause of death listed for Brancheau was drowning and traumatic injuries. One of her SeaWorld colleagues is certain she "loved" the 12,000-pound orca and that he loved her back. [44], Although Brancheau's widower, Scott Brancheau, hired a Chicago law firm that specializes in wrongful-death litigation, he has not taken any legal action against SeaWorld. Why were SeaWorld trainers being forced to interact so closely with these enormous wild mammals? The most infamous death occurred when Tilikum pulled trainer Dawn Brancheau under . She resolved to become a 'Shamu' trainer after watching a 'Shamu' show during a family vacation in Orlando. Meanwhile, six years after the tragedy SeaWorld announced it was ending its programme of breeding the orcas in captivity. Dukes' parents filed a lawsuit against the park that year but later withdrew it. Her spinal cord was severed, and she had sustained fractures to her jawbone, ribs, and a cervical vertebra. Per the report, Brancheau was badly bruised, cut, and scraped. Sign up to the Daily Star's newsletter. Dawn Brancheau was one of SeaWorlds star performers. To retrieve the dead trainer's whistle from the bottom. Other witnesses claimed they saw Tilikum "hit her" as she tried to escape, and that at points he was carrying her around by her arm, and torso. The cause of death was listed as drowning and traumatic injuries that the 23-foot-long killer whale caused on Brancheaus 57, 123-pound frame. Subscribe for new episodes. Cloud, formerly of Cedar Lake, Ind., passed away February 24, 2010 doing what she loved. Msg/data rates may apply. As the emergency siren echoed through the enormous marine park, employees raced to the pool and tried to corral the agitated creature with nets, throwing food into the pool in an attempt to distract him. She had worked at the park, training enormous marine mammals, including Tilikum, for 16 years. Also among Wednesday's revelations was a brief account of how much SeaWorld treasured Brancheau. The autopsy report said that Brancheau died from drowning and blunt force trauma. She was survived by her husband, Scott. [10], Brancheau was born Dawn Therese LoVerde in Cedar Lake, Indiana, and was the youngest of six children. Thomas said it was when she was removed from the water and he observed that she had been scalped that he realised that she had died. The OnlyFans model and Twitch streamer's Estonian stalker is back, attempting to break in before leaving a mysterious box and key at the front door of her home. [4] Moving from pool to pool in the complex, they eventually directed Tilikum to a smaller, medical pool, where it would be easier to calm him. Text UGLY to 73822 to tell UGGs to choose vegan materials and stop supporting the mutilation and violent killing of sheep! Dawn Brancheau had been working with some of the deadliest beasts of the deep for more than 15 years. [15], She was featured on SeaWorld billboards throughout Orlando. The autopsy was released as SeaWorld and Brancheau's family await a court ruling on their request to keep private a video of the fatal attack. A homicide inquest found that the whales had prevented Byrne from climbing out of the tank and ruled her death an accident. How smart are killer whales and can they decide to kill a person? Brancheau lived her dream for 15 years. Blake-Lamb Funeral Home. It is still not known what triggered Tilikum to attack that day. Her scalp was completely torn off from her head, and her left elbow and left knee had been dislocated. She added that from her viewpoint, he never let Dawn come to the surface, despite the petite trainer at one point appearing to do her best to escape his jaws, and frantically swimming up for air. The killer whale snatched the 40-year-old trainer from a poolside platform in its jaws and thrashed her around underwater, killing her in front of a horrified audience Feb. 24. The medical examiner reports that no drugs or alcohol were found in Dukes' system. SeaWorld finally gave up on appealing its violations, but not before OSHA presented damning evidence that seems to imply that SeaWorld may be responsible for its own trainers death. The six-page report reveals that Brancheau's left arm and part of her scalp were ripped off. The incident is the subject of Blackfish, a documentary film available to watch on Netflix. Turn on desktop notifications for breaking stories about interest? SeaWorld successfully challenged the report, which OSHA agreed to withdraw. However, on this occasion, the ban was solidified by an Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) intervention. Staff "asked for control" by slapping the water, but Tilikum ignored them, and became more agitated the more people tried to get Dawn from his jaws, "thrashing violently back and forth". And she drowned. Her scalp was completely torn off from her head, and her left elbow and left knee had been dislocated. Despite massive public relations efforts on SeaWorlds part to smooth over the incidenti.e., death by killer whaleby characterizing it as play that went a bit wrong, the autopsy shows that Tilly was not in the mood for affection. [4]:347[5][11], In 2000, she appeared on NBC affiliate WESH and talked about staying physically fit in order to deal with the intense rigor of working with orcas.
Long Term Effects Of Wildfire Smoke, Handy Basketball Hoop Assembly, Shark Attacks In Panama City Beach 2021, Jo Ann Castle, Articles D
Long Term Effects Of Wildfire Smoke, Handy Basketball Hoop Assembly, Shark Attacks In Panama City Beach 2021, Jo Ann Castle, Articles D